Blair's Golden Road Blog - Keith and Donna's Last Days with the Dead
By Blair Jackson
Over in one of the discussion groups on DeadNet Central recently, someone was fondly recalling Keith and Donna’s final show, at the Oakland Coliseum on Feb. 17, 1979, noting it was a rare great show from their late period with the band.
My own experience of that show was not particularly positive. I went into it with a bad attitude, because I was bummed that the band had “sold out” by playing the 15,000-seat basketball arena so close on the heels of my beloved Winterland closing less than two months earlier on New Year’s Eve. I had trouble finding a good spot on the crowded floor that night, which reinforced my negative opinion of the Dead’s decision to play there, and at the time I thought the show was only OK. It wasn’t until many years later, when I finally deigned to check out a tape of the show I had dissed, that I realized what a good show I had “missed.” (It isn’t pretty, but it happens!)
I could be mistaken, but my memory of that night is that I did not know that it was going to be Keith and Donna’s last show with the Dead. (Others in the discussion group said they did know.) Though I was an editor at BAM magazine at the time and we even had a Grateful Dead news column called “Dead Ahead” (penned by David Gans), I wasn’t really privy to insider gossip in those days. I certainly didn’t know that the couple was fighting like cats and dogs offstage or that Keith was battling a serious addiction to opiates - or that Jerry was, for that matter. (I believe I first heard that in 1980.)
I remember being quite disappointed when I learned that Keith and Donna were departing. I felt the Dead’s music took a quantum leap when Keith joined in the fall of ’71, and I enjoyed Donna’s contributions when she came onto the scene the following year. I liked her vibe, she was easy on the eyes, and I appreciated that touch of gospel she brought to the harmonies. Unlike some Dead Heads, I was never bothered by her “wailing” in “Playing in the Band” or her little vocal improvs following “Scarlet Begonias.” Yes, there were occasionally pitch issues, but they were much more noticeable to me once I started seriously collecting tapes in the late ’70s than they were when I was in-the-moment at shows. I also felt a special kinship with them because I spent many a night standing 10 to 15 feet from them at Jerry Garcia Band club shows between 1976 and ’78. That’s where Keith really shone brightest, and I always loved the warm rapport between Jerry and Donna in those intimate settings. When Jerry started playing with the horn-heavy band Reconstruction in early ’79, I didn’t stop to think about why he had dissolved the group with Keith and Donna. I just chalked it up to Jerry wanting to go in another direction, as he did occasionally.
Keith in happier times.
There’s no question, however, that the quality of Keith’s playing in the Dead fell off in ’78 and early ’79. It no longer had that sparkle and imagination that marked his best work (’72-’74). Much of what he played in his last year was basic, blocky, chordal stuff. I don’t hear many wrong notes, but he’s not exactly out there on the edge taking chances and pushing the others, as he frequently did, in his own quiet way, in his peak Grateful Dead years. I guess the worst thing you could say about later-period Keith is that he was just taking up sonic space in the Dead’s overall sound. Did this affect the others? No doubt, though it can’t be measured. After all, who knows how much the personal issues of other band members at this time—as chronicled in Dennis McNally’s book, A Long Strange Trip, and other places—also colored the group’s music.
It seems that when people talk about the winter of ’79, the only shows they mention are the January 10 concert at Nassau Coliseum, the one in Buffalo on January 20, and the Oakland show. The first two are famous mostly because “Dark Star” was played at each—10 and 20 days after the song was revived for the first time since 1974 at the Closing of Winterland. I’m on record as saying that the 1/10/79 version is my favorite post-’74 take on the tune; I stand by that. The killer second set of 1/10 also features the only “St. Stephen” of 1979 (and the last until the final three in ’83). The Buffalo “Dark Star” doesn’t have the depth and intensity of the Nassau one (and Bob cuts it off abruptly to go into “Not Fade Away”), but it’s still cool, as is the hurtling “Other One” split by “Drums.” Needless to say, the appearance of these tunes early in the year led to a rash of shouted requests of both tunes in every city the Dead played for the next few months.
After digging those shows for the first time in a while, I decided to go a little deeper into the winter ’79 tour, which was marked by literal cold rain and snow at many stops. I checked out a half dozen other shows and I came away from it surprisingly impressed. True, Garcia’s voice was not in good shape at most shows. At the time, too, there were complaints from the Tour Heads about the amount of repetition of songs and combos—like the “I Need A Miracle” > “Bertha” > “Good Lovin’” trio that showed up so often. Were these same folks complaining about the repetition all through ’77? Probably not. But a lot more people were touring by late ’78, early ’79, and since the shows were hit and miss, quality-wise, during that period, the Great Grumbling about set lists began in earnest!
But what I hear on this tour is a ton of adventurous and exciting playing. There are a few excellent versions of “Scarlet” > “Fire,” including Indianapolis (2/3), Kansas City (2/10) and Oakland (2/17). “China Cat,” absent from the repertoire since December ’77, returns at that Indy show and reclaims a spot in the rotation for the first time since ’74—welcome back, old friend! The versions of “Terrapin” feature somewhat extended middle interludes, and every “Playing in the Band” and every “Estimated” jam goes someplace interesting. The “Eyes” are speedy but often dazzling, with long outro passages. In most of the shows I listened to, Jerry is in no hurry to leave the stage before “Drums” (as he was so often post-’80), instead jamming energetically and inventively for long stretches, sometimes accompanied only by the drummers—listen to the amazing jam after “He’s Gone” on the 2/9 K.C. show. Keith shines occasionally, too, playfully interacting with Garcia from time to time—a flash of the past. But there are also long stretches where he is barely noticeable.
Speaking of the drummers, Mickey and Bill’s solos still show the positive effects of their time in Egypt the previous September, with Mickey playing lots of tar and Bill working out on talking drum many nights. “The Other One” is consistently hot, and Jerry invests his ballads with as much passion as his creaky, fragile voice allows. There are a couple of heartwrenching “Stella”s and a fantastic “Comes A Time” (2/9 K.C.). The still-new “Shakedown Street” is starting to expand in compelling directions, and though you could argue that “Miracle” was a tad overplayed, these versions are all rippin’, with jammy codas (compared to most later ones). “Don’t Ease Me In,” full of pep, appears for the first time since ’74 in Carbondale, Ill. on 2/7, and “Might As Well,” on the shelf for the previous year and a half, is revived at the Kiel in St. Louis on 2/1l. The Oakland show includes two more songs not played since ’74—“Greatest Story Ever Told” and “Big Railroad Blues.” This does not sound like a band that’s just treading water or coasting on their past rep.
That 2/17 Oakland show truly was the end of an era, as the Grateful Dead that returned to performing on April 22, 1979 at San Jose’s Spartan Stadium, with Brent Mydland replacing the Godchauxs, was a totally new animal. I didn’t see the new band until their two early August shows at the Oakland Auditorium (the “new Winterland” I called it), but I was an instant convert to this latest evolution—just as I had been when Keith joined and when Mickey came back. I always trusted the Grateful Dead to do what needed to be done to keep the ball rolling forward. And until fate cruelly intervened about 15 years up the road, they did just that.
As Fate would have it, there is an interesting post just up on the Lost Live Dead site about the choices Garcia had to make when he saw the end of Keith and Donna in the Dead, and consequently his own band. An interesting post on how he might have made his choices, and how he came to his choices. http://lostlivedead.blogspot.com/2012/09/jerry-garcia1978keyboards-jerry...
Always loved Keith and what he brought to the band and sound, its what I grew up on. Never a fan of Donna and all the "Playing in the Band's" she ruined.
A big fan of Brent and what he contributed to the band and the sound. If only they'd taken a break after his passing, we might be having a different discussion. . .
This isn't the first time I've piped in here regarding Keith and Donna. Like you, Blair, I loved them. Keith to me brought a texture to the Dead that was simply irreplaceable. It was the sound that I truly fell in love with. That said, the new Spring 1990 Box has resurrected my appreciation of Brent. Though I saw the bulk of my shows with Brent on keys, I had many issues with his style. But the 1990 box has allowed me to put many of those aside and simply enjoy the music, which was MUCH better than I had realized at the time. I was absent from the Spring 1990 tour and never really paid much attention to those later years on tape. They were, more often than not, a rather depressing experience for me (with the occasional positive surprise thrown in).
But back to Keith and Donna... Like you, I loved Donna. Just as some can't understand how anyone could like her, I can't understand how they could not. As mentioned, she could have the occasional pitch issue, but so did the rest of the band. Her energy and emotional contribution was sorely missed by me upon her exit. The band's vocals never rose to the same level again. Brent may have made fewer mistakes, but his vocal style rarely moved me as deeply, heartfelt as it was. The gospel qualities of Donna touched my soul. And still do. And the female energy was a very welcome balance for the boys, in my opinion.
Keith and Donna's time with the band will always be my personal favorite. All these years later, it still calls to me...
I was sorry I missed the Oakland show but I always thought it to be pretty decent. The set list was fun and ambitious. Not being plugged into any gossip stream I was shocked that Keith and Donna had been fired, mostly because I didn't think anybody had the guts. Not being a musician my comments are totally subjective but I thought Keith's playing when he first joined the band was OK but as time went on he sort of noodled around or just pounded. Donna on the other hand, started off dreadful. I'll never understand it as long as I live. ( Blair, you're not a global warming denier too, I hope). By the end of her tenure she had improved but I never warmed up to her. Brent was a welcome relief and I have no real opinion on Vince. Aside from the tragic ends all these keyboardists had, it strikes me how (seemingly) melancholy they all were. The rest of the band usually projected a positive vibe, at least among themselves. Yeah, the Jerry/Brent thing but that even seemed creepy after awhile. May they all R.I.P.
A bunch of those early '79 shows are not in the vault and only circulate as audience recordings. By and large, though, the quality is very good. If I was going to choose just three to listen to, I'd go with 1/10, 2/9 and 2/10.
I'm not very familiar with this period of Grateful Dead- perhaps my musings have often led me to other eras than this. To borrow the phrase- So many shows, so little time. A casual observation reveals only 3 releases in the year and a half span between Dick's Picks 25 (5/10-5/11/78) and the first Road Trips from the Fall of 79. 2 of these releases- Rocking The Cradle and the Road Trips, From Egypt With Love, are both from the Fall of 78. And of course the Closing Of Winterland New Year's show. There's no release from the time period this article encompasses, nor from the November or December 78 tours (save for 12/31). Add the first few months of Brent's tenure, and there's the Release Gap. I wish more high quality recordings are available of the beginning of 1979- all the more reason a release from this period would be sweet. Although, as is often in the case, I don't know how much of this music exists in the Vault. And on a side note, Release Gaps are not common, and bravo to Blair for shining a light on one. One of the largest release gaps is between Dick's Picks 6- October of 83, and Dick's Picks 21- November of 85.
I went to the January '79 show in Utica. All I really remember is that it was a cold, snowy night and they opened with CR&S. And that it was the only Dead show I ever saw where they didn't play an encore. I remember reading that Keith fell asleep at the piano, but I don't remember noticing it when I was there.