Grateful Dead

Whole Shows? Compilations? All of the Above?

suggested by cosmicbadger, who says:

Once again the debate is raging about whole shows vs compilations.

In the latest Rhino era (since this revamped site was launched). I make the score so far this Total 9 Whole shows: RT2.2 (2/14/68); 3 From the Vault (2/19/71); Winterland Box Set (11/9/73/11/10/73;11/11/73); Cow Palace (12/31/76); To Terrapin (5/28/77); Road Trips Whole Show Download (11/5/79); Road Trips Whole Show Download (11/6/79) Total 7 Compilations: RT1.1 (Fall’79); RT1.2 (Oct 77); RT1.3 (Summer 71); RT1.4 (Oct 78); RT2.1 (Sept 90); RT2.3 (June 74); Rockin’ the Cradle (Sept 78) So its a more or less even balance now, with whole shows slightly favoured (mainly because of the 73 set)

So how about a referendum on future policy. Please post your preference from the following list

A. Whole shows only

B. Mostly whole shows with a few compilations

C. About even balance of compilations and whole shows

D. Mostly compilations with a few whole shows

E. Compilations only If we post our choices A,B,C,D or E in the subject box,then it will be easy to monitor the results. Then we can rant as much as we like in the comment box.

ME here: Absolutely no promises as to "future policy," the makers of which probably have no lack of ideas of their own. And it's certainly not a referendum in the sense of being binding on anyone. But that said, this could be interesting and we might all learn something, and who knows we might get that Anchorage box set,  so have at it!

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Offline
Joined: Oct 27 2008
Thanks Mark

Since both of these are heading to 1958 and kwitt is on both i have revised the list since maustin is after me for both. I think it'll make things a little easier. If anyone objects we will keep the orig list

20.1958
21. kwitt
22. Jake R
23. maustin
24. mdecicco1 (MIA?)

JackstrawfromColorado's picture
Offline
Joined: Jan 2 2009
Out to 1958 today

Along with part 1. Remember that in general I only have 1 source per date! Thanks dstache for the original seed!

20.1958
21. Jake R
22.maustin
23. kwitt
24. mdecicco1 (MIA?)
25.

"It's got no signs or dividing line and very few rules to guide"

Offline
Joined: Apr 8 2010
A Reseed Would Great!

I'm also signed up for part 1.

Thanks for reseeding these JSFC!

20.1958
21. Jake R
22.maustin
23. kwitt

maustin's picture
Offline
Joined: Aug 3 2010
I'll jump on that.....

20.1958
21. Jake R
22.maustin

Thanks for the reseed

JackstrawfromColorado's picture
Offline
Joined: Jan 2 2009
Has anyone heard from mdecicco1?

I am still working on re-seeding this and part 1. If I remember right he hasn't been around? I could just go straight to 1958, I know he would be in still since he responded back to me about part 1. It would actually make it easier if I could just send parts 1 and 2 to 1958 in one package, which is what I am going to do unless mdecicco1 speaks up real soon.

19. mdecicco1
20.1958
21. Jake R
22.

"It's got no signs or dividing line and very few rules to guide"

Offline
Joined: Oct 27 2008
Reseed?

Can anyone help?

Offline
Joined: Oct 27 2008
And if this one is still going, i'm in

17. birdsong1969nj in 1-7 out 1-25
18. dr zevon
19. mdecicco1
20.1958
21. Jake R

dstache's picture
Offline
Joined: Sep 10 2007
update

mdecicco has not received this vine, so it looks like it is Dr. Z who is stalling this one. Let us know what is going on, Z

JackstrawfromColorado's picture
Offline
Joined: Jan 2 2009
Status

I don't think Dr Z has been around in quite awhile. This is not the first vine that has disappeared after being sent his way. I am thinking it may be time to start cleaning up some of these lists like what we did last year when vines started stalling and disappearing. I understand getting tired of doing the vine thing but I do not understand how you can keep receiving vines in the mail and then not send them along. Its like they are saying "Screw it I am done vining and now I am keeping any vine that hits my mailbox". That's the only explanation. Well I guess its not the ONLY explanation but still...

"Here's my half a dollar if you dare .. double twist when you hit the air. Look at Julie down below .. the levee doing the dopaso"

dstache's picture
Offline
Joined: Sep 10 2007
lovelight

Yeah, the jam is great, pretty unique actually.

Anyone know where this vine is? 1958 has NOT received it. I will PM Dr. Z and mdecicco

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Whole Shows? Compilations? All of the Above?