• 69 replies
    clayv
    Default Avatar
    Joined:

    The complete Portland Memorial Coliseum show from 5/19/74

    6 LP Set
    180-gram Vinyl
    Limited to 7,500 copies
    Release Date: September 7th, 2018

Comments

sort by
Recent
Reset
  • matchewy
    Default Avatar
    Joined:
    @ROYALRJR and @rodrigodiaz
    I would lay my money down that all the vinyl reissues and RSD releases you mentioned used hi def digital for the final mastering (with the exception of the Mofi releases). A majority of the reissues on vinyl are using digital sources, although some are more transparent than others. The Bruce Springsteen vinyl reissues explicitly state they are mastered from digital. Even Mofi occasionally uses digital sources when the analog is not available, but they are transparent about it and release those titles on their Silver Label series. I have many of these. They sound really good. That being said, we are not talking about simply pressing a CD master to vinyl. When digital sourcing is used, is has been sampled at higher rates to digital, and then that hi res digital source is used for the vinyl. The net of what I am saying is the vinyl pressed from hi res digital still includes more information than a CD, and it still sounds damn good if you enjoy the sound of vinyl. I own all of the special edition live GD vinyl releases. They all sound really great, and I have no regrets about dropping the scratch for them, even the ones I already have on CD. I also own the GD re-issues of the WB albums. Again, no regrets, even though I feel pretty confident they are all mastered from a digital source. My point is I wouldn't necessarily be too persnickety about whether or not digital sourcing has been used. If you enjoy the sound and experience of vinyl, you will be happy with releases sourced from hi res digital. I pay more attention to the pressing plant used as a few plants use better wax and have higher standards for QC than others. Also, the engineer who did the mastering is important (Chris Bell, as was mentioned, is a solid engineer).
  • stoltzfus
    Joined:
    $129+ for one show chopped up on vinyl?
    shazam.
  • Seth Hollander
    Joined:
    4LPs?
    LP1 = 22:54 & 23:27LP2 = 22:56 & 9:39 LP3 = 14:11 & 22:11 LP4 = 18:24 & 16:12 LP5 = 6:38 & 20:50 LP6 = 18:51 & 6:10 currently the longest side is 23:27 (side B) D (LP2,B) & E (LP3,A) combine to 23:50 and H (LP4,B) & I (LP5,A) combine to 22:50. If the audio quality difference between a 23:27 side and a 23:50 side is as negligible as it appears, "MissingJerry" has a point. Also, the first 3 LPs could be reconfigured to : 16:09/15:58/21:56/20:25/18:39/22:11 without altering the song order. Doesn't reduce the number of discs, but looks a little more elegant to my eye. As it is, I hope for the audiophiles that sides D, I, & L play at 45rpm (and I hope for the stoners that they don't! "Woah, dude, what's wrong with Jjjjjeeeeerrrrrrrryyyyyyy?").
  • ROYALRJR
    Default Avatar
    Joined:
    Plangent Process
    From my understanding, Plangent converts analog to digital to do its job. Therefore Any vinyl release that uses Plangent is not analog. The complete dead boxset with the orange slipcase was done by Chris Bellman analog and the MOFI Workingman's Dead and American Beauty are analog also. Its better to buy the hi rez downloads when Plangent is used. I saw a talk here in Denver by David Glasser and he explained the process so that's where I got my info. Take care.
  • snafu
    Default Avatar
    Joined:
    4 Lps ?
    4 records would require reordering of songs which I believe no one would want, or making some longer than optimal sound quality and audio levels
  • rodrigodiaz
    Default Avatar
    Joined:
    Plagnet Process
    I would like more information on the process used to master the vinyl. I need to know if this is a digital recording put on vinyl or analog. I try to not buy any digital releases on vinyl because it undermines the whole rational for having the vinyl. RSD was great because all the concerts were recorded and released in analog. Neil Young Wilco The National David Bowie Lou Reed And the Dead.
  • daverock
    Joined:
    Whoops
    Having just checked with the Taping Compendium and my copy of Deadbase-10 from 1995- this show looks very special indeed. All the shorter songs get praised, with Greatest Story being singled out as one of the best versions. The jam following Truckin' sounds great too, with its inclusion of the Mind Left Body jam. My copy of Deadbase has this show as the 4th best of the year-with only 28th June, 18th June and 19th October ahead of it. 19th October was considered the best show of the year, which I am not sure I would agree with.But it was a list complied 23 years ago.
  • direwulf
    Joined:
    Missing Jerry
    Ok I'm sorry no need to get snappy...why did you quote me with a "huh"? Feels like that is implying a request for an explanation and I have no idea your age or experience with records, it's the internet...Im guessing here. The timing doesn't seem like it would work out even with your extra 1-2 minutes.
  • daverock
    Joined:
    6 LP Set
    The positive is that it presents the music in the way it was played on the night. The downside is that this means we are being presented with 4 albums worth of music on 6 albums. So, I am not sure about buying this one. I've bought the cd box set. You can't judge a show by its set list-but to basically buy a show twice-it has to have something extra special-and I'm not sure this one has. I am normally drawn by Dark Star, Playin' and The Other One-which are all conspicuously absent on this set. I guess I'll give it some more thought-check what the Taping Compendium says about it, and go one way or the other.
  • reijo29
    Joined:
    Limited
    I love vinyl but I may have to hold out for the variant color version in 2019. I'm still waiting for the Veneta vinyl re release. I won't chase an original Veneta one like I did in trying to obtain the Cornell LP. Re release them all, let them flow
user picture
Default Avatar

Member for

6 years 1 month

The complete Portland Memorial Coliseum show from 5/19/74

6 LP Set
180-gram Vinyl
Limited to 7,500 copies
Release Date: September 7th, 2018

user picture
Default Avatar

Member for

13 years 5 months
Permalink

I received my 6LP box set that I had preordered for around $130 months ago. So excited when it came, but it had a horrible manufacturer’s defect with a huge gouge across the entire side one of album one. A straight deep groove from the center hole to the edge of the disc. I have emailed dead.net twice in the last 8 days to try and see if I can get an exchange, even if it was just the first album, and NO response. I’m feeling burned by this because I pay a lot of money for every vinyl release and this was my first real issue. I wish customer service would do the right thing and contact me. I agree with the other comments on here about the mixing and general sound quality of the other discs, but honestly I could live with that IF they would exchange the first LP only. There had to be better Wall of Sound converts to choose from that did not have the audio issues, but I’m surprised in the comments to not see anything else about having a gouged side one that is inaudible due to the loud popping. Customer service, please do the right thing and contact me. Thanks!
user picture

Member for

15 years 6 months
Permalink

Can we get more vinyl please. Maybe some E72 or Warlocks '89 shows. Thank you.
user picture
Default Avatar

Member for

16 years 10 months
Permalink

Sounds like the main mic feed to tape got pulled or tripped over or something and they didn't figure it out for a few songs. The vocals we hear there are bleed from all the PA behind them bleeding in to the instrument mics and probably didn't affect the crowd. At least they've put them all on one side so you can skip if you want, but boy it's hard to skip that lineup of songs. Otherwise loving my vinyl!! The team they have mastering and cutting these things is awesome. Don't change a thing and keep em coming!!
user picture
Default Avatar

Member for

5 years 7 months
Permalink

I am having a similar experience, they have replied albeit very slowly - usually a couple of days in between replies. Almost a week for the first reply. I've had a horrible experience thus far. The box I received was banged up and damaged, no fragile label anywhere, one corner of the shipping box was completely ripped open. On a couple of sides - big river especially - had extremely bad and loud popping. On top of that, they should have absolutely notated the sound mixing issues so everyone knew ahead of time. Shady at best. In trying to return them for a refund, they expect you to front the shipping costs, are you freaking kidding me? For a damaged and defective product? Absolutely not - especially with UPS quoting a $41 charge. No way in hell. Still waiting for the response on that one. It's really disappointing and quite frankly insane to see people defending the Side C/Other sound mixing issues. Blind following/ koolaid drinking - how dare anyone question the almighty dead.net team. They are charging $130 and for that price, they absolutely should be held to a higher standard. Not to mention amazon is now selling it for $103 shipped. Really frustrated with this release and this whole experience, was looking forward to the vinyl and even bought an extra copy as a gift. They need to get their ducks in a row.
user picture
Default Avatar

Member for

5 years 7 months
Permalink

Thanks
user picture
Default Avatar

Member for

7 years 2 months
Permalink

I ordered this from Amazon a couple days ago after first test driving online--what a show! I haven't opened it yet, but Amazon customer service has always been top notch, and I have no doubt that if there's a defect, the return will be a snap. As OP says, Amazon is much cheaper, also. I'm also skeptical about this limited release of 7,500. They said the same thing when they released the Cornell show in vinyl a couple years back, then they promptly pressed a bazillion copies when the first run sold out. I don't buy records to resell and make money, but I went to a lot of effort to make sure I'd get a copy of Cornell, based on the premise that there would only be a limited press. That experience eroded my trust in this outfit no small amount.
user picture

Member for

6 years 3 months
Permalink

Brewrow, I have the CD set, and all the songs that you mentioned Jerry sounding low on sound fine to me. He's really low in the 1973 shows, but I just didn't hear what you're talking about. I went back and sampled all the songs you mentioned and he sounds like he's at a normal level. Are you sure it's not your system? Honeyman, if you can afford 2 turntables, you can afford 2 copies of a release, so you don't have to get up to flip the record.
user picture

Member for

10 years 6 months
Permalink

I doubt they’re any different, but I was referring to the LP. With all the comments I was a bit concerned that I may have been a bit jumpy on my comments. But after revisiting my vinyl copy, I feel the same way. I LOVE THIS SHOW, but Jerry’s guitar is really low for most of this show. Can I hear him? Absolutely! Just wish it was a bit more clear. Again, not “hating”, just giving my ever so humble opinion.
user picture

Member for

12 years 7 months
Permalink

I'm just getting started. Listened to A and B last weekend and didn't notice a problem. This morning started with C and am a little concerned. The vocals are there somewhere but out of anything close to balance with the instruments. I'm hoping it is due to original tape and not the mastering and/or pressing of my set.Fingers crossed :-(
user picture

Member for

10 years 6 months
Permalink

Let me first remove the egg from my face. Train, you were correct about my system. It IS faulty. My left speakers volume is really low and it turns out my receiver’s speaker connection is bad!!! Can’t wait for my new receiver so I can hear this show proper!!! Sorry for the bad info everyone.
user picture
Default Avatar

Member for

15 years 3 months
Permalink

At least I'm not alone. Those songs are vocal ones or at least its a big part of it. Oh well. Never perfect

user picture
Default Avatar

Member for

5 years 1 month
Permalink

I have the same issues with vocals on side C for the vinyl box set. Is there a remedy offered for this or did I get screwed out of $100?

I hate to be the bearer of bad tidings, but.....

On the other hand, you have just bought yourself a fantastic record of The Dead at the absolute peak of their powers.

user picture
Default Avatar

Member for

16 years 9 months

In reply to by TDCarowindz

Permalink

I am deterred from buying this release mostly because they have chosen to track this show onto 12 (twelve!) sides, which is just ridiculous. It can be very easily packed into 9, saving one entire disk, without interfering with its running order or making any one side longer than about 24 minutes. Vinyl is already inconvenient - making you change a disk every 10 minutes (or 6) even more so! Reading the mix issues many are talking about just confirms my belief that I don't need this. Too bad - hot show, love vinyl.

user picture

Member for

8 years 6 months

In reply to by jawknee

Permalink

There is nothing wrong with the vinyl mix, it’s the same mix that is on the CD.
Vocal drop outs, etc, are on the master reels.

user picture
Default Avatar

Member for

7 years
Permalink

Why would you pick this lousy recording for vinyl release.

user picture

Member for

9 years 8 months

In reply to by TJPD2

Permalink

I'll admit it does seem crazy to have only one 6 minute song on a side. This could have been condensed greatly. But I have found myself playing this album more than any other Dead show this year. It's hardly picture perfect...but I keep getting drawn back to it. Far more than I am to Dave's 34 -even though, logically speaking, that is a better show and recording.

product sku
081227930585